May 19, 2020
Good Samaritans, first-responders and clinical caregivers gift David Hines, 46, with second chance at life

ALLEN, Texas — When Carrie Hines heard the banging on her door on the morning of April 29, she assumed her husband, David, was back from his morning run and playing a joke on her.

But the Allen man had never even made it to his destination of Celebration Park.

David Hines with first-responders and caregivers

David Hines, flanked by Allen Fire Department officials and some of the Texas Health nurses who cared for him.

Passing motorists would notice David, 46, face-down on a sidewalk off Malone Road. Someone called 911. Zepp Moore, a nearby resident, ran over and checked for a pulse but found none. A woman then started chest compressions while Moore kept time.

Allen Police Officer Anthony Garcia, the first emergency responder to arrive on the scene and a friend of the Hines family, couldn't see the face of the man as he approached but recognized the royal blue T-shirt that he wore.

"I don't know if that's David's favorite color, but he wears a lot of royal blue shirts and I know he runs almost every day around that time. That's how I knew it was him," Garcia said.

The officer took over chest compressions from the woman and then, after Allen firefighters/paramedics arrived on the scene, rushed to the Hines' home to alert Carrie.

"I opened the door and Anthony Garcia was there and he said, 'Get in the car!'" Carrie recalled. "I thought he was teasing. I said, 'I'm in my pajamas' but he said, 'Something happened to David. Get in the car.'"

At the scene, Carrie saw her husband on the ground and emergency crews continuing CPR on him. She remembers a woman standing off to the side with her hands raised in prayer.

"Someone came over and said, 'We're not getting a heartbeat but we're doing everything we can,'" Carrie recalled. "I was just terrified."

But thanks to the efforts of those Good Samaritans, first responders and caregivers at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Allen, David made a remarkable recovery. Less than a week after suffering the heart attack, David is now back at home with his wife and two children.

"He was clinically dead. He had no heartbeat. They saved his life out there on that jogging path that day," said Danny Williams, a Division Chief for the Allen Fire Department. "From the person who called 911 to those who did compressions to our personnel who show up and take over from where others left off to those in the emergency room who we hand the patient off to — it's just a team effort that brought him back to where he is now. It's pretty incredible."

Therapeutic hypothermia

David's heartbeat would return after being shocked with a defibrillator in the ambulance ride to the hospital.

Carrie, who was driven to the hospital in Garcia's patrol car, had to initially wait outside due to visitor restrictions. She was expecting the worst when she was later allowed inside along with her father.

"When they said I could bring a support person, I was thinking they're going to tell me he's gone," They're going to tell me he's gone,'" Carrie said. "I was just begging someone to tell me that he was OK. They came in and told me the vent was breathing for him."

Interventional cardiologist John Lee, M.D., said David had suffered an arrhythmia while running, leading to cardiac arrest.

Because it was unknown how long David had been down, Lee recommended therapeutic hypothermia — the process of cooling, then warming back up David's body to try to prevent further damage from swelling of the brain.

"Any significant amount of time the brain goes without oxygen, there is an increased risk that you can suffer irreversible brain damage," Lee said. "That's something we always worry about when someone goes down and loses a pulse and we don't know how long they'd been gone for."

David was cooled down to about 92 degrees for about 24 hours before the warming process was started on the afternoon of April 30. He had returned to his normal body temperature by 11 p.m. that night, beginning the excruciating wait for his family to see if he would wake up.

"That's your time of hope, when you can see how much brain damage there is and whether or not they actually wake up from their coma," Lee said.

As she anxiously waited, Carrie relied on updates from David's nurses, whom she said, "Made me feel like I could call them anytime." She also had friends who worked at the hospital, like dietitian Sarah Mitchell and registered nurse Julie Benesh, who would check in on David, hold his hand and tell him that Carrie loved him.

"Julie called me at 5:39 a.m. (May 1) and said, 'He opened his eyes, Carrie! He opened his eyes!'" Carrie recalled. "I thought I won on the lottery. I woke up my kids, my mom who was here. I said, 'He opened his eyes!'"

Orchestrated by the Lord

But concerns remained that morning that David was still somewhat non-responsive. Carrie, convinced hearing her voice might help, headed to the hospital determined to see him.

"My dad missed the exit and I was so mad," Carrie said. "I said, 'I'm going to cry for one minute, then I'm going to be strong again.' But while he was turning around, my friend Julie texted me and she said, 'He's awake! Vent is out! He's talking!"

At the hospital, Carrie got to visit with her husband and was soon joined by Garcia.

"He asked, 'What happened?'" Carrie recalled. "He knew my name. He knew Anthony's name. It was just a miracle."

Garcia said seeing his friend gave him chills.

"I can't explain it. It was weird thinking back to whenever I got there on the scene and I was like, I don't know if he's going to make it, to seeing him smiling really big at me," Garcia said.

Lee was also pleasantly surprised when he walked into David's room to see him responding and alert.

"That was just amazing," Lee said "Especially since we don't how long he was out for, I was actually very surprised that he had made such a tremendous recovery. The fact that he had a bystander start CPR before anyone showed up, that saved his life."

That Monday, Lee placed two stents to repair the blockages — one 70 percent and the other 99 percent — in David's left anterior descending artery, often referred to as the widow-maker.

The next day, on May 5, David got to go home.

An active man who plays sports and had experienced no previous problems, David believes his heart issue was hereditary.

"I've never felt short of breath, never had chest pain. It came out of nowhere," David said. Other than some soreness and a little short-term memory loss, he said he now feels fine.

Days after his return home, a parade of some 100 well-wishers, led by Garcia in his patrol car, drove by the Hines home to celebrate his recovery. The couple says they're grateful for everyone who played a part in saving David's life — from the first responders and caregivers who treated him to the Good Samaritans who stopped to help that April morning, including the woman who performed chest compressions but has shied away from any attention.

"Every single minute was orchestrated by the Lord and it worked out," Carrie said.

Related News

About Texas Health Resources

Texas Health Resources is a faith-based, nonprofit health system that cares for more patients in North Texas than any other provider. With a service area that consists of 16 counties and more than 7 million people, the system is committed to providing quality, coordinated care through its Texas Health Physicians Group and 29 hospital locations under the banners of Texas Health Presbyterian, Texas Health Arlington Memorial, Texas Health Harris Methodist and Texas Health Huguley. Texas Health access points and services, ranging from acute-care hospitals and trauma centers to outpatient facilities and home health and preventive services, provide the full continuum of care for all stages of life. The system has more than 4,100 licensed hospital beds, 6,400 physicians with active staff privileges and more than 26,000 employees. For more information about Texas Health, call 1-877-THR-WELL, or visit  

We use cookies and similar technologies to enhance your experience on our website and help us
understand how our site is used as described in our Privacy Statement and Terms of Use. By
using this website, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.
Accept and Close